I was completely gobsmacked to find out that John had not only returned to the Inn, and brought his wife, but also had landed the room next to me, which had resulted in his and my lives being intertwined again.
I didn't really know what to say or do in that moment, so I excused myself, under the premise of giving them some space to adjust to their situation. When I returned to my room, there was already a message on my phone from John: "Thanks for keeping cool. We'll talk."
I laid on the bed and stared at the ceiling. I was annoyed at myself for implicitly endorsing John's lie, but what was I supposed to do, tell Mary "Oh, I already know your husband, we used to sleep together, and now it will be so much easier and more convenient for us to do so if we so desire. Also I kind of kidnapped him for the last year." I felt some frustration toward John, but a lot more toward myself. My own bad decisions are coming home to roost, with compound interest.
After a while, there was a knock at the door. John/Dakota entered, dressed in a pink tank top and white linen shorts -- girly but functional, with a lot of bare skin, his hair in a loose ponytail. Behind, looming over him, was the much-taller Mary/Cassandra, dressed in a black spaghetti strap top bodysuit with high-waisted high-cut shorts overtop, emphasizing her pinup girl physique.
"So, Mary thought," John said, still behaving like we were unacquainted, "We should get to know each other better. How does brunch sound?"
I wanted to say I wasn't really hungry, but I was in the body of a 22-year-old athlete -- I was starved.
Reluctantly, I went along. I couldn't even tell you what was said, because the entire time I was fixated on how messed up it all was. John as Dakota was aloof, unable to meet my eyeline. Mary was like a deer learning to walk. What I know of her, she's a buttoned-down sort of lady. She was definitely cognizant of the way people were looking at her, her eyes constantly searching the room.
"I feel like I'm wearing a Halloween costume I can't take off," she said at one point, inflected with both annoyance and awe at the situation. "Good gracious, what kind of person does this to their skin?" she said, displaying Cassandra's intricate tattoo sleeves. "Does she not know one day she's going to be an old woman?"
The day passed and John and I weren't getting any opportunities to talk -- frustrating but understandable, since I can't see how Mary would let her husband wander off in this body, or how John would explain wanting to. It was midnight when I got the notification.
"You up?"
"Yeah," I texted back, "We should talk in person if you can get away."
"Meet me out front," John wrote.
A few minutes later, there we were. I guess I shouldn't have felt so weird towering over him -- the height difference was less extreme than when he had been Cayden, but at the same time, seeing John as a pretty blonde was trippy. I sat on the front step with my eyes forward, unable to look at this girl -- I didn't want how attractive she was looking to color my perception that it was John inside, and he had a lot to answer for.
"So," he began to say in a low voice, "You've got to believe this was not planned."
"How could I possibly?" I snapped back. "You and me, here, together? With Mary? You must have hacked my emails."
"Hack your emails?" he scoffed, "I can't even get my Apple watch to work. It's purely coincidence."
He produced his phone and showed me an exchange between him and Mary from a few weeks earlier. The sender said "That place in Maine called back -- there's openings in July and September."
"I've got quarterly board meeting in September, so July it is. I know it's quick but I'm very excited."
"Me too."
John explained that Mary was on the board of a nonprofit that would be meeting in September, so they couldn't pick that vacancy.
"It's still too insane to think this is a coincidence," I grumbled. "I feel like somebody has been manipulating my whole life for years."
"Well if they have, it's not me," John sneered, "I wouldn't have known how to make this happen, and it's the last thing I would have wanted. I was aiming to get further away from you."
"So what did you want?"
He heaved a big sigh and said, "Same thing you want. A second chance. There was no saving Mary's and my relationship as it was. But she's a good person and doesn't deserve to be hurt. As far as she knows, we've just been estranged for a while and I was going to put a serious effort into reconciling. But I couldn't do it as... you know, me. I couldn't look at her and see a partner or a lover anymore. I was hoping that we could become two people who could love each other. Or on the flipside, two people who could just be friends. Let her down easy."
"You got your wish," I growled.
"Cut me some slack," he said, "I didn't do anything worse than what you did, and I had noble intentions. This inn is going to do its magic thing no matter what, you've said so yourself. Why not get the benefit?"
It always feels like I'm in a first-year Ethics class with John -- which is, paradoxically, why I wanted to sleep with him as Ryan.
"So if Mary had become Dustin, you would have tried to make it work?" I asked.
"I should've been so lucky," he snorted -- cutely, I might as well say. I could feel his eyes scan me, but I ignored it.
He put his hand on my knee, but I moved it off. I didn't want to signify to John that that door was in any way, open, no matter what we may look like.
"It may sound counterintuitive," John said, "But this was the only way Mary and I could have an honest relationship. With my having been to the Inn and her not, there was an imbalance of experience. Now at least, we can make an informed choice how we want to live the rest of your lives."
"Sounds like you've really thought it over," I grunted, "Like you've got yourself convinced."
"You of all people should know what an intoxicating experience it is to know that the inn exists and does what it does."
"That doesn't make it a good thing," I sighed.
There was no winning the argument, and no point to it -- what was done was done. By now we'd pretty much locked into the fabrication that we were strangers and he'd never been to the Inn. If I blow his cover now it's going to bring up a lot of questions I'd rather not answer either, and make me look like I had something to do with it. I'm an accessory after the fact.
Not much of a fresh start.
"Go be with your wife," I said, exasperated. "Do whatever you can to make this experience palatable for her. I guess I'll go delete my posts." I felt kind of sad that Marc Green was going to disappear from this blog forever, but as therapeutic as it is to spill your guts to strangers it's not always practical or fair to others.
"Nah, leave 'em up," John said. "Write whatever you want. She's not a reader, she only uses her phone for gardening videos."
I did offer "Dakota" a friendly side-hug as we parted ways. I'm satisfied -- for the time being -- that we're on the same page and fundamentally want the same things. I watched him go back in... and annoyingly, he turned back to see me watching, which caused some embarrassment and provoked in him a smirk. I waved him off. The last thing I want is to come any further between these two... let them sort out whatever it is their relationship is going to look like without me. I'll find... literally anything else to do.
-Marc/Dustin